Amaze and delight your wedding guests with ice cream from Bartleby’s. We offer ice cream wedding cakes, groom’s cakes, dessert tables, and more to help make your special day truly extraordinary. Download our wedding cake order form or contact us to start a wedding order today!

Like the rest of our menu, our wedding offerings are

GOURMET • Made with the highest-quality ingredients, including local pasture-raised dairy. We think wedding cakes (and all desserts) should taste good!

FRESH • Created from scratch in our Chicago kitchen just days before delivery, for the most vibrant flavors and luscious textures

CUSTOM • Choose from our full menu of ice cream flavors, baked goods, sauces, and toppings—or make a special off-menu request—to create the cake of your dreams. Fully vegan and gluten-free cakes are available!

EXTRAORDINARY • Not just an ice cream wedding cake—a delicious, one-of-a-kind ice cream cake that will blow your guests’ minds

Two-tier cake with olive branches


  • Ice cream cakes can be 1–4 tiers tall.

  • Orders must be finalized, with a 50% deposit, at least one month before the wedding.

  • A tasting of selected ice cream flavors, baked goods, and decorations can be arranged for a fee of $60 (credited toward your balance if you place an order).

  • We can work with a florist to have real leaves or flowers added to the cake.

  • We will work with you or your venue manager to create a delivery, storage, and serving plan with no melting!

Contact us with questions and ideas or download our order form to start your order today!

Bartleby's 3-tier cake at Cafe Brauer
Bartleby's single-tier wedding cake