Choose the menu item you want, then select from the options below to customize it with your favorite ice cream flavors and accompaniments. Or check out our cakes of the month to see what combinations we’re recommending.

Ready to commit?

Looking for more inspiration? Check out our photo galleries for some of our favorite creations.



Ice Cream Cakes

Each cake comes with two layers of ice cream (1 or 2 flavors), two layers of a crumbled baked good, whipped cream frosting, and up to 3 decorations, including a message.

6" Round

$55 custom; $50 cake of the month

Serves 6–10


8" Round

$65 custom; $60 cake of the month

Serves 8–12

10" Round

$85 custom; $80 cake of the month

Serves 12–16

9" Square

$100 custom; $95 cake of the month

Serves 20–25

Ice Cream & Baked Goods

Ice Cream

$12 pint/$22 quart

A container of any flavor, ready to scoop. Pint serves 4–6; quart serves 8–12.


Ice Cream Subscription


Three months of happiness, delivered three pints at a time. Flavors selected by Bartleby’s.


Ice Cream Sandwiches


10 ice cream sandwiches, each made with a hefty scoop of ice cream (choose one flavor) and two homemade chocolate chip cookies. Serves 10.


Chocolate Chip Cookies (Regular or Vegan)


A dozen (12) chocolatey cookies made with luscious dark brown sugar and bittersweet chocolate. Regular cookies are made with flavorful cultured butter, while vegan cookies are made with refined coconut oil.




A dozen (12) of our eye-poppingly rich, chewy brownies, packed with brown butter and Dutch-processed cocoa.




Like brownies, but without the cocoa and with a knockout punch of butterscotch flavor. A dozen (12) per package.


Combo Pack

$20 pint + half-dozen; $36 quart + dozen

Your choice of ice cream flavor together with your choice of baked good. Dessert accomplished!


V = vegan. See the FAQs page for information about potential allergens.


Dairy ice creams are made with fresh cream and milk from local, family-owned Kilgus Farmstead; vegan ice creams are made with a blend of cashew butter, coconut cream, and oat milk


Dairy or Vegan

Cocoa powder, bittersweet chocolate, and a baseline of decaf coffee



Dairy or Vegan

Rich and sweet, steeped with locally roasted decaf beans


Cookies and Cream

Dairy or Vegan

Sweet cream ice cream with big chunks of sandwich cookies


Cookie Dough

Dairy or Vegan

Sweet cream ice cream with homemade, edible, vegan chocolate chip cookie dough balls

Salted Caramel

Dairy only

Dark-cooked caramel balanced with a healthy pinch of salt and rich cream


Dairy or Vegan

Flavored with homemade, organic strawberry puree


Sugar Cone Crunch

Dairy or Vegan

Sweet cream ice cream filled with homemade chocolate-covered sugar cone pieces


Toasted Coconut

Dairy or Vegan

A smooth ice cream flavored with freshly toasted coconut, vanilla, and a hint of almond 



Dairy or Vegan

Flavored with real vanilla beans and pure vanilla extract


Two layers of crumbled baked goods go into every layer cake, adding texture and more delicious flavor





Chocolate cake (V)


Chocolate chip cookies (Regular or Vegan!)


Sandwich cookies (V)


Homemade or gourmet finishing touches to add even more fun to your custom creation

Layer cakes are frosted with whipped cream. Choose one flavor:



Coconut cream (V)

Chocolate coconut cream (V)

Then add some flair:

Caramel sauce 

Chocolate chip cookie dough (V)

Chocolate sprinkles (V)

Chopped sandwich cookies (V)

Fudge sauce 

Mini sugar cones (V)

Rainbow sprinkles (V)

Toasted coconut flakes (V)

Your message can be written in:



Coconut cream (V)

Take Our Advice

Can’t decide? Looking for something that you don’t see here? 


Call or email to discuss how we can make all your ice cream dreams come true. 



We offer fulfillment via pickup (at the Hatchery, 135 N. Kedzie Ave., Chicago); delivery within a 10-mile radius of the Hatchery; or shipping within a 3-day radius by UPS Ground service.





©2020 by Bartleby’s Ice Cream Cakes. Proudly created with